0001Mr.Shoko★.Aug. 31, 2024 (Sat) 18:59:20.36ID:U94Z/JP+9
Why have newspaper subscribers fallen into the minority? The fundamental problem of newspapers flooding the newspapers with “emotional articles” in order to survive “Did newspapers really hate being rejected so much?” | president online
president online
2024/08/30 16:00
Ryosuke Nishida, Professor, Faculty of Crisis Management, Nihon University / Specially Appointed Professor, Tokyo Institute of Technology
Satoshi Osawa, Associate Professor, Faculty of Literature, Kinki University
In March of this year, an article by sociologist Ryosuke Nishida titled “Do we need those ’emotional articles’?” sparked controversy. The background to writing the book was a concern that “recent newspaper articles seem to give too much priority to stories that appeal to personal emotions, and to a neglect of presenting evidence and analyzing data.” We talked with Osawa Satoshi, who wrote the response article, about the problems facing newspapers. Related articles
Will Asahi Shimbun also drop out of the “national newspapers” list? The harsh reality of Kyushu and Shizuoka, the place where the president has a connection, discontinuing their evening editions
Contents
1. Are they prioritizing episodes that appeal to personal emotions too much?
2. “What’s wrong with emotional articles?” Critical comments from within Asahi
3. Criticisms were not received as criticism
4. “They just want to earn derivative views”
5. They should be discussing this in a more open place…
6. Fewer than half of households read newspapers
7. The golden age when the “intellectual middle class” supported newspaper purchases
8. Why did people in the past buy “encyclopedias they don’t even read”?
9. The role of media like Asahi Shimbun, which has survived for over 100 years
10. Concerns about image politics at the root of the “Ishimaru phenomenon”
11. What the media was pushing at the same time as universal suffrage
12. Young people are increasingly communicating through photos and videos
13. Newspapers are turning everything into “essay words”
14. A turning point on which direction speech in general will go
15. The limits of “increasing sales = increasing pageviews”
16. Abema increases sales through online sales of bicycle and boat racing
17. Nikkei Digital Edition is a global example of newspaper DX success
18. How to create a collective and systematic media route
19. Japanese people are on the verge of letting go of language as communication
20. If McLuhan saw the current media environment…
Aren’t we prioritizing episodes that appeal to personal emotions too much?
[Osawa] Nishida’s article “Do you need that ’emotional article’?”, which was contributed to the Asahi Shimbun Digital website “re:ron”, caused a great stir. I too could not help but respond from a historical perspective, writing an editorial in the July issue of the monthly magazine Voice titled, “Journalism becoming a ’small newspaper’ again.” Could you tell us about the background of the article? [Nishida] That article was written based on a concern that I had originally had. He feels that recent newspaper articles have given too much priority to stories that appeal to personal emotions, and have neglected to present evidence and analyze data. He has said similar things before, for example, in a roundtable discussion held in the summer of 2023 by the Mainichi Shimbun’s Open Newspaper Committee, of which he is a member, he said, “I feel uncomfortable with articles that are based on anecdotes. It seems to be popular, but the world has become so complex that this episode is just one example, so I wonder how much meaning or reason there is to reading it.” In the Asahi article, they described this tendency to be “episode-centered” and “emphasize narrative” as “emo (sentimental)” and included it in the title, which elicited an enormous response and reaction. [Osawa] The fact that a catchy headline is the driving force behind its spread is very typical of the social media era. “What’s wrong with emotional articles?” Critical comments from within Asahi
[Nishida] This article sparked debate on the Asahi Shimbun Digital platform. There is a feature called “Comment Plus” that is available to paid members, where external experts, Asahi Shimbun reporters, editorial writers, etc. can add comments to articles, which readers can read. There have been many mixed comments posted here. While there were many positive comments from outside the company, such as “I thought the same,” most of the comments from within Asahi were critical, such as “What’s wrong with an emotional article?” Strangely. I was left with the strong impression that this was a gathering of people who liked the place. (Omitted)
*See source for full text.
president online
2024/08/30 16:00
Ryosuke Nishida, Professor, Faculty of Crisis Management, Nihon University / Specially Appointed Professor, Tokyo Institute of Technology
Satoshi Osawa, Associate Professor, Faculty of Literature, Kinki University
In March of this year, an article by sociologist Ryosuke Nishida titled “Do we need those ’emotional articles’?” sparked controversy. The background to writing the book was a concern that “recent newspaper articles seem to give too much priority to stories that appeal to personal emotions, and to a neglect of presenting evidence and analyzing data.” We talked with Osawa Satoshi, who wrote the response article, about the problems facing newspapers. Related articles
Will Asahi Shimbun also drop out of the “national newspapers” list? The harsh reality of Kyushu and Shizuoka, the place where the president has a connection, discontinuing their evening editions
Contents
1. Are they prioritizing episodes that appeal to personal emotions too much?
2. “What’s wrong with emotional articles?” Critical comments from within Asahi
3. Criticisms were not received as criticism
4. “They just want to earn derivative views”
5. They should be discussing this in a more open place…
6. Fewer than half of households read newspapers
7. The golden age when the “intellectual middle class” supported newspaper purchases
8. Why did people in the past buy “encyclopedias they don’t even read”?
9. The role of media like Asahi Shimbun, which has survived for over 100 years
10. Concerns about image politics at the root of the “Ishimaru phenomenon”
11. What the media was pushing at the same time as universal suffrage
12. Young people are increasingly communicating through photos and videos
13. Newspapers are turning everything into “essay words”
14. A turning point on which direction speech in general will go
15. The limits of “increasing sales = increasing pageviews”
16. Abema increases sales through online sales of bicycle and boat racing
17. Nikkei Digital Edition is a global example of newspaper DX success
18. How to create a collective and systematic media route
19. Japanese people are on the verge of letting go of language as communication
20. If McLuhan saw the current media environment…
Aren’t we prioritizing episodes that appeal to personal emotions too much?
[Osawa] Nishida’s article “Do you need that ’emotional article’?”, which was contributed to the Asahi Shimbun Digital website “re:ron”, caused a great stir. I too could not help but respond from a historical perspective, writing an editorial in the July issue of the monthly magazine Voice titled, “Journalism becoming a ’small newspaper’ again.” Could you tell us about the background of the article? [Nishida] That article was written based on a concern that I had originally had. He feels that recent newspaper articles have given too much priority to stories that appeal to personal emotions, and have neglected to present evidence and analyze data. He has said similar things before, for example, in a roundtable discussion held in the summer of 2023 by the Mainichi Shimbun’s Open Newspaper Committee, of which he is a member, he said, “I feel uncomfortable with articles that are based on anecdotes. It seems to be popular, but the world has become so complex that this episode is just one example, so I wonder how much meaning or reason there is to reading it.” In the Asahi article, they described this tendency to be “episode-centered” and “emphasize narrative” as “emo (sentimental)” and included it in the title, which elicited an enormous response and reaction. [Osawa] The fact that a catchy headline is the driving force behind its spread is very typical of the social media era. “What’s wrong with emotional articles?” Critical comments from within Asahi
[Nishida] This article sparked debate on the Asahi Shimbun Digital platform. There is a feature called “Comment Plus” that is available to paid members, where external experts, Asahi Shimbun reporters, editorial writers, etc. can add comments to articles, which readers can read. There have been many mixed comments posted here. While there were many positive comments from outside the company, such as “I thought the same,” most of the comments from within Asahi were critical, such as “What’s wrong with an emotional article?” Strangely. I was left with the strong impression that this was a gathering of people who liked the place. (Omitted)
*See source for full text.
その「エモい記事」いりますか 苦悩する新聞への苦言と変化への提言:朝日新聞デジタル
■Re:Ron連載「西田亮介のN次元考」第7回 このところ、エピソード主体の「ナラティブで、エモい記事」を新聞の紙面で見かけることが少なくない。ナラティブとは物語や語りを意味する。要は、お涙ちょうだい…
朝日新聞も「全国紙」から脱落するのか…社長ゆかりの地「九州・静岡」が夕刊廃止に至った厳しすぎる現実 「編集局一強」の構図が変化しつつある
朝日新聞社が10月1日から、福岡・山口など3県で夕刊の発行を休止する。同社が8月2日朝刊で、読者に知らせた。段階的に夕刊発行を縮小してきたが、今回は西部本社(北九州市)を構える福岡県も対象で、「紙離れ」や…
なぜ新聞を取る人が少数派に転落したのか…生き残りをかけて「エモい記事」を氾濫させる新聞の根本問題 「新聞社って、こんなに否定されることが嫌だったのか」
今年3月、「その『エモい記事』いりますか」と題した社会学者の西田亮介さんの記事が論争を呼んだ。執筆の背景には「最近の新聞記事は個人の感情に訴えるようなエピソードを優先しすぎて、エビデンスの提示やデータの分析が疎かになっているのではないか」と...
0057Anonymous Donburako.Aug. 31, 2024 (Sat) 19:11:08.71ID:5UsdAnPb0
>>1
It’s a medium where you can get away with lying
and it got exposed.
It’s a medium where you can get away with lying
and it got exposed.
0097Anonymous Donburako.Aug. 31, 2024 (Sat) 19:20:00.24ID:bM9zfsDR0
>>1
Speaking of emotional articles, there are a lot of articles written about how easy it is to live on welfare
But when you read them, they’re definitely being extravagant in vain lol, and the person who wrote them has a weird sense of style lol.
Speaking of emotional articles, there are a lot of articles written about how easy it is to live on welfare
But when you read them, they’re definitely being extravagant in vain lol, and the person who wrote them has a weird sense of style lol.
0110Anonymous Donburako.Aug. 31, 2024 (Sat) 19:23:37.90ID:ucH7i+9K0
>>1
Is it because online news is enough?
Is it because online news is enough?
0112Anonymous Donburako.Aug. 31, 2024 (Sat) 19:23:59.64ID:pjPIB+Ue0
>>1
Newspaper costs over 4000 yen
Rakuten Mobile costs just over 3000 yen.
Newspaper costs over 4000 yen
Rakuten Mobile costs just over 3000 yen.
0002Anonymous Donburako.Aug. 31, 2024 (Sat) 19:00:31.85ID:nK596tg30
That’s because gafa was born.
0003Anonymous Donburako.Aug. 31, 2024 (Sat) 19:00:35.86ID:8pY7S4Ne0(1/2)
Give up already. Newspapers have reached their end of life. No matter how cleverly you handled things, this situation was inevitable.
0004Anonymous Donburako.Aug. 31, 2024 (Sat) 19:00:49.42ID:ZUsQp5mY0
I subscribe to a newspaper because I want the ads for the local supermarket, but it’s a waste. I wonder if there’s a place that will just deliver the ads.
0006Anonymous Donburako.Aug. 31, 2024 (Sat) 19:02:09.98ID:sMBCcs5R0
>>4
Just stop by the supermarket often.
Just stop by the supermarket often.
0014Anonymous Donburako.Aug. 31, 2024 (Sat) 19:04:20.08ID:g2S36R1u0(2/2)
>>4
My mom has an app on her tablet that lets her see a list of supermarket advertisements, and she checks it in the morning.
I really enjoy it.
My mom has an app on her tablet that lets her see a list of supermarket advertisements, and she checks it in the morning.
I really enjoy it.
0040Anonymous Donburako.Aug. 31, 2024 (Sat) 19:09:03.22ID:6e129ndh0
>>4
You can do it on a computer or app, but it’s a pain.
I don’t have to go to the store every time.
When I get it in paper form, I end up buying it by chance.
I guess this is how drugstores put discount coupons in.
You can do it on a computer or app, but it’s a pain.
I don’t have to go to the store every time.
When I get it in paper form, I end up buying it by chance.
I guess this is how drugstores put discount coupons in.
0007Anonymous Donburako.Aug. 31, 2024 (Sat) 19:02:36.79ID:LcrgM3GN0
In this information society, we don’t look at paper.
0008Anonymous Donburako.Aug. 31, 2024 (Sat) 19:02:44.50ID:g2S36R1u0(1/2)
The articles aren’t up to date. Online articles are updated so the information is fast. You can’t overcome the time loss.
0009Anonymous Donburako.Aug. 31, 2024 (Sat) 19:02:46.63ID:6xRTtVij0(1/2)
It’s simply boring as a piece of reading material. There was a time when I was obsessed with it (ideological bias aside).
0010Anonymous Donburako.Aug. 31, 2024 (Sat) 19:02:59.20ID:BS2AJ19f0(1/7)
Disposing of paper is a pain. What I want is hair, not paper.
0012Anonymous Donburako.Aug. 31, 2024 (Sat) 19:03:34.65ID:vOzcva2/0
Because there are more journalists now.
0016Anonymous Donburako.Aug. 31, 2024 (Sat) 19:04:43.18ID:IpEEQ3wA0
Aren’t people who subscribe to newspapers more interested in the paper than the articles?
0019Anonymous Donburako.Aug. 31, 2024 (Sat) 19:05:20.17ID:9NXOTc830
Newspapers and television have lost credibility, and we live in an age where most information can be covered by a single smartphone, but it’s hard for idiots to understand this.
0021Anonymous Donburako.Aug. 31, 2024 (Sat) 19:05:33.74ID:wM+ra53x0
Who can pay 5,000 yen a month to a company that not only can’t write the truth or facts, but also fabricates articles and helps encourage neighboring countries to attack Japan? Newspapers have been the enemy of the people since before the war.
0022Anonymous Donburako.Aug. 31, 2024 (Sat) 19:05:43.70ID:j72Dvr/d0(1/5)
It’s true that Asahi’s evening edition is annoying because it puts its own reporting on the front page, whereas Nikkei’s evening edition has a sprinkling of regular news on the front page.
0025Anonymous Donburako.Aug. 31, 2024 (Sat) 19:06:43.43ID:GqzwNbEO0(1/2)
We need you guys to pack up the shit.
0026Anonymous Donburako.Aug. 31, 2024 (Sat) 19:06:50.53ID:DIQBvkhw0(1/5)
It’s because they’re doing so much propaganda, just look at how they treat Trump.
0027Anonymous Donburako.Aug. 31, 2024 (Sat) 19:07:40.76ID:wxEcFYnx0(1/2)
Even though they are in a disadvantageous position, biased reporting is only getting worse.
0029Anonymous Donburako.Aug. 31, 2024 (Sat) 19:07:43.64ID:zydhMbRE0(1/4)
I don’t have any money so I stop buying things that I think are wasteful and I don’t need.
0030Anonymous Donburako.Aug. 31, 2024 (Sat) 19:07:45.98ID:BS2AJ19f0(2/7)
If there were no television and no newspapers, there would be no wars. Or are there wars that start with smartphones?
0099Anonymous Donburako.Aug. 31, 2024 (Sat) 19:20:07.58ID:s4CYlTOF0(1/2)
>>30
Corona.
Corona.
0031Anonymous Donburako.Aug. 31, 2024 (Sat) 19:07:48.92ID:xEJGdAAs0
I think I might stop subscribing to newspapers. Paper media has its advantages, but I find it annoying when they try to force their views on me.
0032Anonymous Donburako.Aug. 31, 2024 (Sat) 19:08:05.68ID:38jAxtqN0
It’s mainly on the internet, but when you open an article and use the name of a famous actress in the title, the image that pops up is of an old man. Should we stop that? I don’t like people who can’t tell the difference between right and wrong.
0033Anonymous Donburako.Aug. 31, 2024 (Sat) 19:08:13.36ID:v3ec4TRD0
yes. The efforts that newspapers have been making up until now have now come to fruition.
0034Anonymous Donburako.Aug. 31, 2024 (Sat) 19:08:20.78ID:4oLRlJL50
Because it’s not just paying money to read a political propaganda flyer lol.
0038Anonymous Donburako.Aug. 31, 2024 (Sat) 19:08:59.39ID:SM/6Xk/X0
Personally, I think the Asahi Shimbun has fallen to the bottom when it was revealed that they were writing articles full of lies. The newspaper industry is evading the 10% consumption tax and still doing whatever they want.
0051Anonymous Donburako.Aug. 31, 2024 (Sat) 19:10:23.96ID:DIQBvkhw0(3/5)
>>38
Now that I think about it, it was a reduced tax rate lol
It’s like giving money to a thief.
Now that I think about it, it was a reduced tax rate lol
It’s like giving money to a thief.
0039Anonymous Donburako.Aug. 31, 2024 (Sat) 19:09:00.14ID:DIQBvkhw0(2/5)
Goebbels only succeeds at first, but he is soon seen through and ridiculed.
0041Anonymous Donburako.Aug. 31, 2024 (Sat) 19:09:14.57ID:av+6eoDi0
I just want the morning paper, so it should cost about 1,500 yen a month.
0046Anonymous Donburako.Aug. 31, 2024 (Sat) 19:10:04.81ID:ii3gDTP60
I guess more and more people are starting to think that online news sites are enough instead of newspapers. Idiots who are against newspapers themselves should think about what the majority of the sources on this board are based on lol.
0048Anonymous Donburako.Aug. 31, 2024 (Sat) 19:10:07.14ID:E3sErOED0(1/2)
The information is delayed, while online news is faster and can be seen from many different perspectives.
Comments