Ex-BOJ Deputy Hiroshi Nakaso reflects on 25 years of monetary easing to combat deflation, acknowledging its side effects.
1Flea market ★.Dec. 23, 2024 (Mon) 15:32:16.33ID:vkeg0mqf9
Hiroshi Nakaso, chairman of Daiwa Institute of Research and former deputy governor of the Bank of Japan, said in an interview with the Asahi Shimbun that the monetary easing measures of the past 25 years aimed at escaping deflation in which prices continued to fall, “we were aware of the side effects, but we had no choice but to pursue them.” The Bank of Japan is currently in the process of raising interest rates, and the report states that its monetary policy aimed at escaping deflation has “largely accomplished its mission,” but that the government’s growth strategy and fiscal reconstruction “cannot be said to have produced sufficient results.” The interview was conducted on the 10th, ahead of the Bank of Japan’s release on the 19th of a “multifaceted review” examining its monetary easing policies over the past 25 years. Nakaso served as deputy governor under former Governor Kuroda Haruhiko for five years from 2013. In April 2013, the Bank of Japan began “unprecedented” monetary easing as a pillar of Abenomics. It pushed forward with large-scale purchases of government bonds and exchange-traded funds (ETFs). Nakasone reflected, “We felt that we had to do something, so we decided to take the measure, even knowing that side effects would occur, in order to turn the situation around.” However, the initial target of a 2% inflation rate, which was to be achieved within around two years, was not achieved. “Contrary to the short-term strategy, prices did not rise as expected.” The Bank of Japan decided to implement a negative interest rate policy in January 2016, and in September of the same year, it decided to introduce yield curve control (YCC) to suppress long-term interest rates. Nakaso said, “Every time we have faced challenges or limitations, we have introduced new mechanisms and done our best,” adding that the YCC, which was considered unusual even on a global scale, “was the ultimate form of unconventional monetary policy that we arrived at through repeated trial and error.” Nevertheless, the price target was not achieved during Nakaso’s term, and it was not until Russia’s invasion of Ukraine in February 2022 that the inflation rate exceeded 2%. “Growth strategy is weak” “Sustainable fiscal structure”
In March of this year, the Bank of Japan announced that it would appoint Kuroda as the next prime minister… (The following is a paid version, 1590 characters remaining)
Asahi Shimbun, December 23, 2024, 15:00.
In March of this year, the Bank of Japan announced that it would appoint Kuroda as the next prime minister… (The following is a paid version, 1590 characters remaining)
Asahi Shimbun, December 23, 2024, 15:00.
大規模金融緩和「副作用を覚悟で踏み切った」 元日銀副総裁の中曽氏:朝日新聞デジタル
日本銀行副総裁を務めた中曽(なかそ)宏・大和総研理事長が朝日新聞のインタビューに応じ、物価が下がり続けるデフレからの脱却を目指した過去25年の金融緩和策について「副作用も認識していたが、踏み込まない…
26Anonymous Donburako.Dec. 23, 2024 (Mon) 15:47:11.90ID:M+FHFSe40
>>1
Side effects are only relevant if the product is effective.
Side effects are only relevant if the product is effective.
34Anonymous Donburako.Dec. 23, 2024 (Mon) 15:53:09.01ID:6LuYchC40
>>1
At the time, Yellen asked me, “What about exit?” That is the current dilemma facing the Bank of Japan.
At the time, Yellen asked me, “What about exit?” That is the current dilemma facing the Bank of Japan.
44Anonymous Donburako.Dec. 23, 2024 (Mon) 16:12:12.36ID:iGj2t8so0
>>1
(,,´j`)<The current state of affairs is the result of monetary easing in an attempt to make the bubble dream come true again!
To put it bluntly.
(,,´j`)<The current state of affairs is the result of monetary easing in an attempt to make the bubble dream come true again!
To put it bluntly.
2Anonymous Donburako.Dec. 23, 2024 (Mon) 15:33:29.11ID:jFJRGSFm0
As a result, I guess what he’s trying to say is that it’s only natural that you guys will suffer because of high prices lol.
58Anonymous Donburako.Dec. 23, 2024 (Mon) 16:33:44.78ID:yW1wxzRX0
>>2
What are you talking about? Continued price increases are the goal. A sustained fall in prices is abnormal in a capitalist world. If we leave it alone, the economy will collapse.
What are you talking about? Continued price increases are the goal. A sustained fall in prices is abnormal in a capitalist world. If we leave it alone, the economy will collapse.
4Anonymous Donburako.Dec. 23, 2024 (Mon) 15:33:54.47ID:0uX9g9lC0
Morphine, huh?
5Anonymous Donburako.Dec. 23, 2024 (Mon) 15:34:02.39ID:fmERBAgA0
Without admitting failure there is no progress.
6Anonymous Donburako.Dec. 23, 2024 (Mon) 15:34:41.39ID:F70Tk6Mw0
If you are aware of the side effects, stop after 2 years. It’s no excuse since it didn’t have any major impact.
29Anonymous Donburako.Dec. 23, 2024 (Mon) 15:48:56.14ID:egDzKZqM0
>>6
The real main effect is to raise the Nikkei average
It really worked.
The real main effect is to raise the Nikkei average
It really worked.
7Anonymous Donburako.Dec. 23, 2024 (Mon) 15:34:46.60ID:bl2D4irN0
Because of Aso and the Ministry of Finance, fiscal spending is insufficient 😠😠😠😠😠.
9Anonymous Donburako.Dec. 23, 2024 (Mon) 15:35:42.62ID:fmERBAgA0
They are busy trying to protect themselves. Both Kuroda and Nakaso are incompetent hard workers who have made huge mistakes.
14Anonymous Donburako.Dec. 23, 2024 (Mon) 15:37:46.15ID:64IzRc+d0
The side effects don’t affect me anyway.
15Anonymous Donburako.Dec. 23, 2024 (Mon) 15:38:51.34ID:nYpBS7MI0
First of all, it’s strange to talk about escaping deflation. You start by investing in people, which improves products and services, boosting economic power, which leads to higher wages, which results in rising prices, or inflation.
16Anonymous Donburako.Dec. 23, 2024 (Mon) 15:39:01.83ID:z5pFy/8I0
WWII “We sacrificed the kamikazes but lost the whole country”
Lost 30 Years “We sacrificed the deployment but lost the whole country”
Lost 30 Years “We sacrificed the deployment but lost the whole country”
17Anonymous Donburako.Dec. 23, 2024 (Mon) 15:39:33.96ID:FSxwjuvm0
Get long-term interest rates to 3% quickly.
18Anonymous Donburako.Dec. 23, 2024 (Mon) 15:41:33.64ID:hOFlQ+NQ0
The Bank of Japan’s job is to stabilize prices. If they’re the government’s dog, they won’t learn from their defeat in the last war.
19Anonymous Donburako.Dec. 23, 2024 (Mon) 15:41:57.65ID:ckjrKIci0
I understand getting away from deflation, but raising taxes doesn’t make sense. They’re not just taxing us twice, they’re taxing us three or four times, so get rid of them. How long are you going to make us pay the special income tax for reconstruction, you idiot?
20Anonymous Donburako.Dec. 23, 2024 (Mon) 15:42:27.31ID:V+dvCmjf0
Now is the only time we can play the “interest rate cut” card!
If we don’t raise interest rates now, the global economy will stagnate and we will have no cards to play!
If we don’t raise interest rates now, the global economy will stagnate and we will have no cards to play!
21Security Guard [lv.7] [Sprout].Dec. 23, 2024 (Mon) 15:42:48.59ID:CJXH/4vU0
Deflation was so severe that it took 10 years for side effects to appear after the start of quantitative easing. If they hadn’t done it, things would have gotten awful.
22Anonymous Donburako.Dec. 23, 2024 (Mon) 15:42:54.08ID:EPPyq9YR0
Money has a different meaning if you give it to someone who wants to start a business than if you give it to someone who just wants to save their cash.
Even if you ease monetary policy, you can’t control who gets the money.
To be honest, the idea that value can be created with just money is a kind of unfounded religion.
If I had to say, it’s just telekinesis.
Even if you ease monetary policy, you can’t control who gets the money.
To be honest, the idea that value can be created with just money is a kind of unfounded religion.
If I had to say, it’s just telekinesis.
25Anonymous Donburako.Dec. 23, 2024 (Mon) 15:44:09.98ID:IkpzTNXz0
No one takes responsibility anymore. This is how it always is in Japan.
27Anonymous Donburako.Dec. 23, 2024 (Mon) 15:48:27.70ID:J9gaPCW+0
A self-proclaimed government that pretends to heal with one hand while sabotaging and stealing with the other.
28Anonymous Donburako.Dec. 23, 2024 (Mon) 15:48:29.67ID:sZQPt/Na0
As a form of morphine it was extremely effective, but the fact that it was addictive is something to be regretted.
31Anonymous Donburako.Dec. 23, 2024 (Mon) 15:50:20.29ID:aaJBqAjK0
There were only side effects.
36Anonymous Donburako.Dec. 23, 2024 (Mon) 15:55:52.85ID:Ibz8NXgo0
If they had combined this with wage increases from the start, we might have seen better results. I think the Bank of Japan did a good job, but 10 years later, the political and business worlds are still talking about wage increases.
37Anonymous Donburako.Dec. 23, 2024 (Mon) 15:57:25.64ID:NhoGjH9C0
The exit is still blocked though…
38Anonymous Donburako.Dec. 23, 2024 (Mon) 15:57:35.21ID:d6hQzTba0
“I can’t say that sufficient results have been achieved.”
Not sufficient results = not a failure.
Not sufficient results = not a failure.
40Anonymous Donburako.Dec. 23, 2024 (Mon) 16:01:21.59ID:p8QDwKK20
The gap just widened.
41Anonymous Donburako.Dec. 23, 2024 (Mon) 16:05:06.45ID:LR0BE8Oe0
Well, it’s not me who will be suffering from the side effects, so I can prepare myself for it easily.
42Anonymous Donburako.Dec. 23, 2024 (Mon) 16:09:46.55ID:z8KlMLP80
ETFs are a no-no, and I’m not allowed to sell them since they’re the actual salaries of Bank of Japan employees.
49Anonymous Donburako.Dec. 23, 2024 (Mon) 16:20:55.39ID:RleR/XhQ0
If you go to a department of economics, you’ll end up being ignorant about economics.
50Anonymous Donburako.Dec. 23, 2024 (Mon) 16:22:54.92ID:iVMUCrF10
>>49
That’s not quite right.
People who are bad at math and can’t even do differential or integral calculus go to the economics department, so the end result is that there are a lot of people who are bad at economics.
That’s because the departments are separated into arts and science.
That’s not quite right.
People who are bad at math and can’t even do differential or integral calculus go to the economics department, so the end result is that there are a lot of people who are bad at economics.
That’s because the departments are separated into arts and science.
51Anonymous Donburako.Dec. 23, 2024 (Mon) 16:23:27.99ID:3INeCxKH0
The side effects of the weak yen are terrible: Japan’s asset value has been halved.
Comments