Can nuclear bombs really save the Earth from an asteroid collision? Latest simulation experiments examine.

movie
0001@Killer Whale ★ Security Guard [lv.23] [Seedling].Oct. 1, 2024 (Tue) 14:38:19.50ID:xYbQ8DUn9
10/1 (Tue) 13:00 Forbes Japan
Research results have been published that show that experiments and computer simulations have confirmed that it may be possible to change the orbit of an asteroid that poses a threat to Earth by using the energy emitted by a nuclear explosion. However, a prerequisite is that the asteroid be discovered before it’s too late. About 66 million years ago, a “planet-destroying” asteroid measuring 10 km in diameter collided with Earth. The Chicxulub impact caused a global mass extinction, wiping out an estimated 76% of all living species, including the dinosaurs. An asteroid the size of Chicxulub has a chance of hitting Earth once every 100 to 200 million years, with smaller impacts occurring more frequently. There are currently about 1,200 asteroids on the Near Earth Object (NEO) hazard list. The list includes any object larger than one kilometer in diameter that could theoretically collide with Earth within the next 1,000 years. These neos are too small to cause global destruction, but large enough to devastate entire regions. Proposed defense mechanisms to neutralize these threats include using a spacecraft to crash into the asteroid, or detonating a bomb on the asteroid’s surface. In theory, the kinetic energy of this impact could be harnessed to push the asteroid off a collision course with Earth. The Dual Asteroid Reorientation Test (DART) conducted in 2022 successfully altered the orbit of the 150m diameter asteroid Dimorphos. For larger celestial bodies, the use of nuclear weapons has been proposed. Detonating a nuclear bomb could potentially shatter part of the asteroid into smaller pieces that would either not hit Earth at all or would burn up in the atmosphere. However, if the asteroid is made of loosely packed material, it may simply absorb the shock waves without affecting the asteroid’s motion. In this study, a research team led by Nathan W. Moore of Sandia National Laboratories in Albuquerque, New Mexico, proposes an alternative mechanism. Rather than destroying the asteroid outright, the idea is to detonate a nuclear bomb close to the asteroid’s surface. The high-energy x-rays released by the nuclear explosion would vaporize the surface material, and the rapid expansion of this gas would be used like rocket thrust to propel the asteroid forward. (Source below.

核爆弾で地球を「小惑星衝突」から本当に救えるか? 最新の模擬実験で検証(Forbes JAPAN) - Yahoo!ニュース
核爆発で放射されるエネルギーを利用すれば、地球の脅威となる小惑星の軌道を変えられる可能性があることを、実験とコンピューターシミュレーションで確かめたとする研究結果が発表された。ただし、手遅れにならな
0072Anonymous Donburako.Oct. 1, 2024 (Tue) 14:58:52.17ID:KgoeH4hZ0(2/19)
>>1
Well, anyway, “early detection” is everything lol
The sooner we can detect it, the less kinetic energy we need to deflect it from a course that will affect the Earth lol
If it gets too close, it’s too late lol
So this is no time to make fun of astronomy, right? lol
We need to launch as many observation devices as we can lol.
0106Security Guard [lv.7] [Sprout].Oct. 1, 2024 (Tue) 15:09:20.57ID:YxNAYOZl0
>>1
Leftist: “Rather than that, we need welfare for foreigners!!”
0002Anonymous Donburako.Oct. 1, 2024 (Tue) 14:39:13.25ID:yNfKrRdB0
Bruce Willis can do it.
0011Anonymous Donburako.Oct. 1, 2024 (Tue) 14:41:38.60ID:0xkr7Lft0
>>2
I like the scene where the woman changes her mind as soon as she finds out that her ex-husband was a hero.
0061Anonymous Donburako.Oct. 1, 2024 (Tue) 14:56:00.91ID:PGeOmCZG0
>>2
The Aerosmith theme song is the main focus, and the movie is just a bonus music video
So what we need is Steven Tyler, not Bruce Willis.
0003Anonymous Donburako.Oct. 1, 2024 (Tue) 14:39:36.78ID:YiomfNVG0(1/2)
If you change the trajectory.
0004Anonymous Donburako.Oct. 1, 2024 (Tue) 14:39:44.08ID:eUfsWRqo0
Space Cowboy?
0006Anonymous Donburako.Oct. 1, 2024 (Tue) 14:40:47.08ID:6Ev1oQh70(1/3)
You’re trying too hard. I just did the math and the rear of Axis will fall on Earth.
0007Anonymous Donburako.Oct. 1, 2024 (Tue) 14:40:55.90ID:xYbQ8DUn0
Push Axis with Ra Cailum!
0008Anonymous Donburako.Oct. 1, 2024 (Tue) 14:41:04.74ID:VvLWCLj00(1/3)
Let’s try it with this asteroid

Asteroid “2024 pt5” will become the “second moon” for two months only from the end of September 2024
news.yahoo.co.jp/articles/c610e1c90f0cdf9415a895fe183cd724b4ef68bf.

0010Security Guard [lv.3] [Sprout].Oct. 1, 2024 (Tue) 14:41:29.41ID:6hNgxgiT0
Imagine if you could stop a dump truck with your breath.
0012Security Guard [lv.6] [new].Oct. 1, 2024 (Tue) 14:42:15.94ID:2WV//rZl0(1/2)
If you miscalculate the trajectory or something, you’ll soon be spending your time praying.
0013Anonymous Donburako.Oct. 1, 2024 (Tue) 14:42:23.58ID:UCOI6ysJ0
If a meteorite were to be broken up and dropped with a nuclear bomb, would it be contaminated with radiation?
0083Security Guard [lv.7] [new].Oct. 1, 2024 (Tue) 15:01:59.55ID:2WV//rZl0(2/2)
>>13
Outer space is full of radiation
If you’re asking if the pieces that exploded and fell through the atmosphere were radioactive, I’d say they were.
0014Anonymous Donburako.Oct. 1, 2024 (Tue) 14:42:34.32ID:YiomfNVG0(2/2)
Can’t we launch nuclear missiles far enough that they won’t affect the Earth?
0020Anonymous Donburako.Oct. 1, 2024 (Tue) 14:45:15.30ID:+fmkxzmd0
>>14
Just launch it from space.
0030Anonymous Donburako.Oct. 1, 2024 (Tue) 14:47:44.43ID:6Ev1oQh70(2/3)
>>14
The question is whether all the countries in the world would be happy if a certain country were to place a nuclear missile with a launch button in space.
0016Anonymous Donburako.Oct. 1, 2024 (Tue) 14:43:18.61ID:SJTZwBl40
It’s impossible unless we unite the world.
0018Anonymous Donburako.Oct. 1, 2024 (Tue) 14:44:47.58ID:c30rytz70
The solar system is good.
0019Anonymous Donburako.Oct. 1, 2024 (Tue) 14:44:58.95ID:8tepwhi20
Shift the trajectory.
0022Anonymous Donburako.Oct. 1, 2024 (Tue) 14:45:25.36ID:4oHnt1Vr0
Should we ask Seagal or Golgo?
0025Anonymous Donburako.Oct. 1, 2024 (Tue) 14:45:58.43ID:G+6V0SCR0
When it actually comes, I wonder if it won’t come straight at you, but will it be like a hellish scene where it gets caught by the Earth’s gravity and spins around as it approaches?
0026Security Guard [lv.3] [Sprout].Oct. 1, 2024 (Tue) 14:46:35.72ID:/py3et0l0
It’s impossible because Bruce Willis isn’t there.
0027Anonymous Donburako.Oct. 1, 2024 (Tue) 14:46:59.24ID:VwAGKat60
It would be quicker to build the Nu Gundam.
0029Anonymous Donburako.Oct. 1, 2024 (Tue) 14:47:40.33ID:x5MtkvTI0
It would be one thing if it exploded in the center, but exploding on the surface is pointless.
0035Anonymous Donburako.Oct. 1, 2024 (Tue) 14:49:42.13ID:ezi5nZX00
>>29
If you detonate it from a sufficient distance, you can avoid a direct hit by slightly shifting the trajectory.
0031Anonymous Donburako.Oct. 1, 2024 (Tue) 14:47:53.48ID:BZcaMDVT0
It’s like asking whether it’s possible to change the trajectory of an oncoming trailer with firecrackers. You can’t beat gravity.
0032Anonymous Donburako.Oct. 1, 2024 (Tue) 14:48:46.77ID:hpxqVA6c0(1/3)
>>31
If it’s a trailer, you can change the start by blowing up the tires.
0033Anonymous Donburako.Oct. 1, 2024 (Tue) 14:49:28.36ID:OtNB4P+k0(1/3)
Jung-eun: “Okay! Let’s pretend we’re making this.”
0034Anonymous Donburako.Oct. 1, 2024 (Tue) 14:49:29.84ID:nTmsbsFz0(2/3)
Grey-faced Buzzard 11, Ready for Lunch.
0036Anonymous Donburako.Oct. 1, 2024 (Tue) 14:50:07.43ID:UfJAKufm0
The movie Melancholia is about an asteroid impact, and when it seems to have gone off course and then comes back, the cool Kiefer Sutherland from 24 casually commits suicide, which made me laugh so hard.
0037Anonymous Donburako.Oct. 1, 2024 (Tue) 14:50:21.64ID:85YaEHs80
It’s just a rock.
0038Anonymous Donburako.Oct. 1, 2024 (Tue) 14:50:33.92ID:3jdlSGlR0
Are you stupid? If you have the New Gundam you’ll have no problem.
0088Anonymous Donburako.Oct. 1, 2024 (Tue) 15:03:19.36ID:62+QTUit0(3/3)
>>38
There are no newtypes.
0040Anonymous Donburako.Oct. 1, 2024 (Tue) 14:51:12.20ID:4woonfLN0
It’s not about saving the Earth, it’s about saving humanity, right? After all, the Earth has been hit by huge meteorites many times in the past and has remained unaffected.
0055Anonymous Donburako.Oct. 1, 2024 (Tue) 14:54:54.21ID:k4Mj93tG0(2/3)
>>40
From Earth’s perspective, it’s like adding a washing machine cleaner.
It gets rid of germs and makes things feel fresh.
0041Anonymous Donburako.Oct. 1, 2024 (Tue) 14:51:33.18ID:GKsVW5il0
(´・ω・`) Humanity will be destroyed.
0042Security Guard [lv.1] [Sprout].Oct. 1, 2024 (Tue) 14:51:42.64ID:p+E5+mF40
They changed Axis’ orbit with the colony laser.
0043Anonymous Donburako.Oct. 1, 2024 (Tue) 14:51:44.13ID:EcjQff2Y0
It’s starting to get exciting.
0047Anonymous Donburako.Oct. 1, 2024 (Tue) 14:52:24.78ID:IQxP5hn+0(1/4)
Let’s build an underground city instead of using nuclear weapons!
0057Anonymous Donburako.Oct. 1, 2024 (Tue) 14:55:25.31ID:z92mkA0o0
It’s incredibly difficult to hit a missile outside the Earth’s gravitational field.
0062Anonymous Donburako.Oct. 1, 2024 (Tue) 14:56:11.93ID:3Bd1ZlFl0
An American managed to do something about it and it was later made into a movie.
0063Anonymous Donburako.Oct. 1, 2024 (Tue) 14:56:26.17ID:FxY7vMIR0(1/6)
Can a nuclear bomb produce shock waves even without air?
It seems to me that it only produces heat rays.
0077Anonymous Donburako.Oct. 1, 2024 (Tue) 15:00:51.93ID:6Ev1oQh70(3/3)
>>63
As you say, there won’t be an explosion, so we’ll use the massive heat to evaporate the surface and then use the resulting repulsive force to shift the trajectory.
0081Anonymous Donburako.Oct. 1, 2024 (Tue) 15:01:20.29ID:KgoeH4hZ0(3/19)
>>63
A long time ago, an interstellar spaceship was planned lol
It was called Orion lol
This one would get thrust by firing a nuclear bomb behind a plate attached to the tail lol
It’s still a valid propulsion engine, but it was almost completely forgotten due to agreements on the use of nuclear weapons in space lol.
0095Anonymous Donburako.Oct. 1, 2024 (Tue) 15:05:02.53ID:vq5weF8y0
>>63
All it takes is a small deflection with a lot of x-ray radiation.
0078Anonymous Donburako.Oct. 1, 2024 (Tue) 15:00:53.07ID:LWfPA+fO0
Just change the trajectory.
0093Anonymous Donburako.Oct. 1, 2024 (Tue) 15:04:31.79ID:8OJXX5ib0(1/4)
If we could find it 10 years before the impact, we’d only need to shift it a little.
Reference: https://asahi.5ch.net/test/read.cgi/newsplus/1727761099

Other languages: 【宇宙】核爆弾で地球を「小惑星衝突」から本当に救えるか?最新の模擬実験で検証, ¿Puede una bomba nuclear realmente salvar a la Tierra de una “colisión de asteroides”? Verificado con el último experimento de simulación.

Comments

Copied title and URL