Hiroyuki Nishimura questions the fairness of Hoshino Gen’s song change for the Red and White Song Battle, sparking debate online.
1muffin★.Dec. 26, 2024 (Thu) 14:21:37.91ID:qylwW0cC9
On the 26th, businessman Hiroyuki Nishimura (48) updated his x (formerly Twitter) account. On this day, singer Gen Hoshino (43) expressed his opinion in response to the sudden change in the song he had planned to perform at the New Year’s Eve “75th NHK Kouhaku Uta Gassen” (7:20 p.m.). On this day, NHK announced that the song that Hoshino Gen had planned to perform at the Kohaku Uta Gassen, “Jigoku de Naze Warui,” would be changed to “Barabara.” “Hell…” was the theme song for the film of the same name released in 2013, and so questions had been raised in light of past reports about director Sono Sion. Hoshino said about the song through his official website, “I collapsed with a subarachnoid hemorrhage in 2012, and wrote the lyrics for this song in the hospital during my battle with the illness. The lyrics were written based on Hoshino’s personal experiences and thoughts. This is not a musical expression of the story of the film, which will be described later. “This is a song that was born from Hoshino Gen, and it is a song by Hoshino Gen,” they said, but then decided to change the song, stating, “Regarding the some who have pointed out that singing this song on the stage of the Kohaku Uta Gassen could be considered secondary victimization, we cannot completely deny that possibility.” In response to this announcement, Hiroyuki said, “If it was a problem that occurred in the film industry, and the director caused the problem, then I could understand them saying, ‘NHK will not air that distribution company’s works.'” However, he added, “However, it was Hoshino Gen, who is in the music industry and only provided the music, who was penalized personally, but the film industry was not punished.” Followers responded with a variety of comments, such as, “That’s a reason that doesn’t make sense,” “You’re right,” “If you think about it calmly, Hiroyuki is right, but it seems like a lot of companies, not just on TV, tend to just apologize and back off when a controversy ensues,” “It’s like this is spreading in a weird way…including the judgment and explanation,” and “It’s a strange story.”
ひろゆき氏、星野源の紅白楽曲変更に「星野さん個人がペナルティー受けて映画業界は…」持論に共感の声(スポニチアネックス) - Yahoo!ニュース
実業家・西村博之(ひろゆき)氏(48)が26日、自身のX(旧ツイッター)を更新。この日、歌手・星野源(43)が、大みそか「第75回NHK紅白歌合戦」(後7・20)で披露する予定だった楽曲を急きょ変
2Anonymous @I’m sorry.Dec. 26, 2024 (Thu) 14:22:13.12ID:u90jT9n80
Sorry about that.
6Anonymous @I’m sorry.Dec. 26, 2024 (Thu) 14:24:26.39ID:qdKbayFJ0
A specialty of the contrarian old man.
7Anonymous @I’m sorry.Dec. 26, 2024 (Thu) 14:25:30.12ID:92dLrfd90
Don’t think Amuse will do everything their way.
8Anonymous @I’m sorry.Dec. 26, 2024 (Thu) 14:26:29.46ID:S/De6kzS0
It’s not like it’s a penalty, or that it’s the only song that’s representative of that artist, so why did he choose that one?
9Anonymous @I’m sorry.Dec. 26, 2024 (Thu) 14:27:19.70ID:YnqB3LNK0
First of all, please explain why you decided to use that 10 year old song for Kohaku.
63Anonymous @I’m sorry.Dec. 26, 2024 (Thu) 16:41:06.78ID:LJpXIkfB0
>>9
They haven’t had a hit song since “Nigehaji.” Don’t make me say it.
They haven’t had a hit song since “Nigehaji.” Don’t make me say it.
10Anonymous @I’m sorry.Dec. 26, 2024 (Thu) 14:27:31.08ID:1g4il9AR0
For Hoshino Gen, love is all that matters.
11Anonymous @I’m sorry.Dec. 26, 2024 (Thu) 14:28:23.77ID:nMr3tB3+0
He has to introduce the song as the theme song for the movie XX, and in this age of compliance, it’s best to refrain from playing it in public. I’d be happy if he played it as much as he wanted at his concerts, which only fans can attend voluntarily. Hoshino also understood his intentions and agreed to it.
13Anonymous @I’m sorry.Dec. 26, 2024 (Thu) 14:29:48.35ID:mcxfrkvD0
There’s no need to change the title of the song just to sing it. He should just decline. I don’t want to hear Hoshino’s song.
14Anonymous @I’m sorry.Dec. 26, 2024 (Thu) 14:29:49.87ID:WHizB60X0
It’s NHK’s fault for requesting this song, but I can understand the backlash. It’s possible to turn them down, but if you’re writing a song for a woman, it’s only natural to be considerate.
15Anonymous @I’m sorry.Dec. 26, 2024 (Thu) 14:29:53.60ID:o+vBPyyT0
What’s the penalty when they can perform at the Red and White Song Battle?!
16Anonymous @I’m sorry.Dec. 26, 2024 (Thu) 14:33:48.94ID:UJM9g7HC0
Well then don’t look.
18Anonymous @I’m sorry.Dec. 26, 2024 (Thu) 14:35:43.64ID:uIVH3fNI0
Even if it’s unreasonable, there have been protests, so there’s nothing we can do about it. Hiroyuki has money, so he can just hire private soldiers and purge the people who gave the lecture, and that will solve the problem. It’s all about fear and violence. Then everyone will obey Hiroyuki.
19Anonymous @I’m sorry.Dec. 26, 2024 (Thu) 14:35:45.80ID:FYTTP2mw0
It’s not a penalty. Being fragmented suits today’s world better.
20Anonymous @I’m sorry.Dec. 26, 2024 (Thu) 14:35:58.19ID:Xh6gtJhx0
That’s your impression right?
21Anonymous @I’m sorry.Dec. 26, 2024 (Thu) 14:36:02.23ID:k8MFijrF0
Penalty? I don’t really understand what that means.
24Anonymous @I’m sorry.Dec. 26, 2024 (Thu) 14:41:37.30ID:NvNukF2T0
I wish the show would stop choosing the songs. I want the contestants to prioritize the songs they want people to hear.
25Anonymous @I’m sorry.Dec. 26, 2024 (Thu) 14:41:40.17ID:sT1dk2vr0
It’s NHK that’s being criticized.
26Anonymous @I’m sorry.Dec. 26, 2024 (Thu) 14:41:40.68ID:q3SG7TlA0
His comments are admirable and he is really thinking about the victim’s feelings.
27Anonymous @I’m sorry.Dec. 26, 2024 (Thu) 14:42:25.05ID:s5/dyFXU0
As expected from Hiroyuki.
28Anonymous @I’m sorry.Dec. 26, 2024 (Thu) 14:45:14.54ID:ksCvqCvG0
Is it a penalty?
Rather, haven’t they both just settled on a normal solution?
It wouldn’t be good to make them sing it like this.
Rather, haven’t they both just settled on a normal solution?
It wouldn’t be good to make them sing it like this.
29Anonymous @I’m sorry.Dec. 26, 2024 (Thu) 14:47:36.14ID:TMdzGDXI0
Why is Hiroyuki so consistently out of sync? Even when he tries to be conscious of it, he ends up saying something sensible along the way.
30Anonymous @I’m sorry.Dec. 26, 2024 (Thu) 14:47:58.18ID:8hVH4kRj0
I get that this is their only representative song, but what kind of penalty would that be? It’s not even a hit this year.
31Anonymous @I’m sorry.Dec. 26, 2024 (Thu) 14:55:22.94ID:Bv+IweZ70
Whose choice of songs is this? You can see how it turns out, right?
32Anonymous @I’m sorry.Dec. 26, 2024 (Thu) 14:57:35.69ID:5wquyD+s0
> It’s not a musical expression of the movie’s story.
I wonder what’s the point of this tie-up.
Cube’s theme song didn’t fit at all.
33Security Guard [lv.4] [Sprout].Dec. 26, 2024 (Thu) 14:58:59.14ID:Ul2SJll70
There was no penalty, right?
34Anonymous @I’m sorry.Dec. 26, 2024 (Thu) 15:05:18.02ID:k6DMKhJn0
I haven’t seen that movie in the first place.
36Anonymous @I’m sorry.Dec. 26, 2024 (Thu) 15:13:29.25ID:AeTBtTgZ0
Even an idiot would know that Hoshino is a main cast member if they looked into it. It’s unlucky, but he’s in a movie with the same title, so it’s tough.
38Anonymous @I’m sorry.Dec. 26, 2024 (Thu) 15:21:15.14ID:/SzxNwe00
I don’t like how Hiroyuki fled the country to France yet still talks like he’s high and mighty. If he has something to say, he should come back to Japan and settle there permanently first. What do you guys think?
39Anonymous @I’m sorry.Dec. 26, 2024 (Thu) 15:21:59.10ID:LWeTaGcN0
This can’t be helped, as it is the result of neglecting to investigate the director’s background and reputation.
40Anonymous @I’m sorry.Dec. 26, 2024 (Thu) 15:25:30.66ID:BOkGGmAV0
I question the nerve of singing “Why Don’t You Live in Hell?” on New Year’s Eve.
41Anonymous @I’m sorry.Dec. 26, 2024 (Thu) 15:27:17.04ID:EeCkRs9w0
There is no other penalty.
42Anonymous @I’m sorry.Dec. 26, 2024 (Thu) 15:29:57.27ID:BAV8nv8Z0
I think they might want to avoid playing this song at the Kohaku.
44Anonymous @I’m sorry.Dec. 26, 2024 (Thu) 15:32:56.37ID:G0opRr3O0
The usual Hiroyuki logic: assume that someone was penalized even though they weren’t, and proceed with the discussion under that premise.
45Anonymous @I’m sorry.Dec. 26, 2024 (Thu) 15:37:13.10ID:B/uUgc9n0
It’s a story about which is better: singing a song about a beautiful world, like “The One and Only Flower in the World,” while secretly acting like a villain and being evil, or singing a song about an unbeautiful world, like “Hell is evil,” while secretly acting like a good person.
46Anonymous @I’m sorry.Dec. 26, 2024 (Thu) 15:42:39.68ID:P6/bEehc0
Hoshino Gen uses difficult expressions but the content is shallow, while Imawano Kiyoshiro uses simple expressions but the content is deep.
48Anonymous @I’m sorry.Dec. 26, 2024 (Thu) 15:44:14.06ID:JWfMVC+00
>>46
You just don’t have the ability to read it.
You just don’t have the ability to read it.
47Anonymous @I’m sorry.Dec. 26, 2024 (Thu) 15:43:51.70ID:cFQnWAKS0
What happens to a tiger’s wings?
49Anonymous @I’m sorry.Dec. 26, 2024 (Thu) 15:44:56.95ID:DYUCrnER0
It’s not a penalty?
53Anonymous @I’m sorry.Dec. 26, 2024 (Thu) 15:52:34.51ID:yuMHA4VD0
It’s like, if you hate the monk, you hate the robe too.
58Anonymous @I’m sorry.Dec. 26, 2024 (Thu) 16:23:50.04ID:+m3wvKLh0
Where is the penalty?
61Anonymous @I’m sorry.Dec. 26, 2024 (Thu) 16:33:58.84ID:mQ0pz8Sj0
No, Penalty just needs to sing a different song, right?
Comments