Are $45 Games Too Expensive? Debate on Entertainment Value Heats Up

tv set

Is $45 for a game worth it? A question sparks debate, with views comparing gaming’s cost per hour to other entertainment forms.

1muffin★.Dec. 21, 2024 (Sat) 15:53:44.78ID:Uk4o3tUd9
“Aren’t games too expensive? Most of them are around 7,000 yen. I was surprised to see that a game I didn’t know much about was priced at 9,500 yen.”
A post expressing surprise at the prices of recent video games has been posted on a major Q&A site, sparking a stir. The discussion began with a simple question: “Why are titles I’ve never heard of so expensive?” and then developed into a more fundamental question: what is the value of entertainment in modern times? There are differing opinions on the appropriateness of prices in entertainment. Looking at the responses we received, many of you pointed out that historically, game prices have been falling compared to the past. Several people commented, “During the Super Famicom era, a new copy cost over 10,000 yen,” and “Expensive software has been around that price since the Famicom era.” Furthermore, taking into account rising prices, some users seem to believe that the actual price has fallen significantly. On the other hand, there are many people who feel that current game prices are “high.” Some respondents pointed out that “now that free-to-play smartphone games have become the norm, the prices of consumer games certainly seem high,” and some sympathized with the questioner’s point about “high pricing for lesser-known games.” However, some analysts have suggested that it is actually “cheap” in terms of the amount of time you can spend playing. The specific calculation given was that “if you play a 7,000 yen game for 100 hours, it will cost 70 yen per hour,” and it was presented that compared to watching a movie at a cinema (2,000 yen per viewing, about 1.5 hours), it is highly cost-effective as entertainment. It was also pointed out that the appropriateness of the price varies greatly depending on the content and volume of the game. For example, in a large-scale open-world game like “The Legend of Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom,” the main story alone can take more than 50 hours, and if you include the additional gameplay elements, you can play for hundreds of hours. Some have said it’s difficult to compare such titles with smaller games that take around 10 hours to complete at the same price. From a software development perspective, some analysts have suggested that it is “even too cheap.” “The credits for modern games are very long, and there are a huge number of people involved in the development. It has been pointed out that the game was created over several years by a variety of experts in music, graphics, programming, and scenario writing. There are also voices saying, “Even free-to-play social games can cost hundreds of millions of yen to develop.” Considering the scale and costs of development, some have suggested that a price range of around 7,000 to 9,000 yen is somewhat reasonable. However, it’s important to remember that the value you get from each game varies greatly. For example, Minecraft can be enjoyed for thousands of hours thanks to its free creativity and limitless ways to play, while a highly polished remake such as the HD-2D version of Dragon Quest III, although it may only take a few dozen hours to complete, offers a new experience that combines nostalgia with the latest technology. The price of a game cannot be measured simply in terms of “high” or “low,” and it seems necessary to look at the overall quality and quantity of the experience. (Omitted)
See the source for the full text.

「ゲームに7000円出す価値ありますか?」質問にツッコミ殺到!? 「100時間遊べば1時間70円」「時間単価で映画より安い」 | マグミクス
「ゲームって、高過ぎでは? 大体どれも7000円」 最近のゲームソフトの価格を目にして驚いたという投稿が大手質問サイトに寄せられ、議論を呼んでいます。
6Anonymous @I’m sorry.Dec. 21, 2024 (Sat) 15:56:52.60ID:m+KSTJS90
Why were Super Nintendo games so expensive?
24Anonymous @I’m sorry.Dec. 21, 2024 (Sat) 16:00:12.89ID:7WmDNTNX0
>>6
The average was 10,000 back then.
53Anonymous @I’m sorry.Dec. 21, 2024 (Sat) 16:05:32.07ID:ohKfK6Xd0
>>6
Because it was a ROM cartridge
and Nintendo’s licensing fees were high.
7Anonymous @I’m sorry.Dec. 21, 2024 (Sat) 15:57:16.11ID:Z0jYEBXj0
I only play Minecraft, but I think it’s actually too cheap.
8Anonymous @I’m sorry.Dec. 21, 2024 (Sat) 15:57:18.23ID:gz/EKQCj0
Games from the company that released Romance of the Three Kingdoms and other games were expensive.
9Anonymous @I’m sorry.Dec. 21, 2024 (Sat) 15:57:40.55ID:7itUtM3A0
Anyone who says games are too expensive for such cost-effective entertainment surely doesn’t play anything else in real life.
21Anonymous @I’m sorry.Dec. 21, 2024 (Sat) 15:59:53.24ID:QiGoO3FW0
>>9
>>Other real-life
I consume it through results, clippings, or summaries.
10Approved.Dec. 21, 2024 (Sat) 15:58:10.13ID:hkYNWuPV0
There’s no game that you can play for 100 hours without getting bored.
46Anonymous @I’m sorry.Dec. 21, 2024 (Sat) 16:03:42.79ID:yqzX2+Zx0
>>10
In my case
Shiren
Splatoon
Animal Crossing.
11Anonymous @I’m sorry.Dec. 21, 2024 (Sat) 15:58:32.19ID:0gtKADJv0
I’m thinking of it as 100 yen per hour, so if you have 70 hours you can make a profit. But if you have 70 hours you’ll get bored halfway through.
32Anonymous @I’m sorry.Dec. 21, 2024 (Sat) 16:01:36.55ID:QiGoO3FW0
>>12
That’s the logic behind the high and low price issue.
13Anonymous @I’m sorry.Dec. 21, 2024 (Sat) 15:58:55.02ID:NlMyRmcL0
Online games are a big profit, you get to keep the actual game, and 7000 yen per game isn’t too expensive.
14Anonymous @I’m sorry.Dec. 21, 2024 (Sat) 15:58:58.61ID:Wkcc42RR0
> If you play the game for 100 hours
Will Zico Soccer hold up under that premise?
17Anonymous @I’m sorry.Dec. 21, 2024 (Sat) 15:59:23.82ID:lhuGmduy0
Buy it second hand.
18Anonymous @I’m sorry.Dec. 21, 2024 (Sat) 15:59:24.76ID:XsqAr/Cg0
The majority of Japanese people would rather spend the same amount of money on social games than buying games.
19Anonymous @I’m sorry.Dec. 21, 2024 (Sat) 15:59:29.39ID:2JFS0WlE0
If you work 100 hours, even if you earn 1,000 yen per hour, that comes to 100,000 yen.
22Anonymous @I’m sorry.Dec. 21, 2024 (Sat) 15:59:58.49ID:iiEHIZJY0
There are people out there who have spent 10+ years on social games that they have no intention of paying for, so there’s no way to know other people’s values.
23Anonymous @I’m sorry.Dec. 21, 2024 (Sat) 16:00:01.63ID:feChyFK30
Personally, I disliked arcades better.
26Security Guard [lv.7] [Sprout].Dec. 21, 2024 (Sat) 16:00:20.49ID:qXKlY8l70
I’ve spent over 2000 hours playing Shiren 5 on Steam.
27Anonymous @I’m sorry.Dec. 21, 2024 (Sat) 16:00:28.84ID:AiiGRcEJ0
It feels a lot cheaper than it used to be.
29Anonymous @I’m sorry.Dec. 21, 2024 (Sat) 16:00:48.72ID:0gtKADJv0
I don’t spend a single yen on smartphone games. But the games these days are so long and long that they go on sale anyway, so I end up waiting for them.
30Anonymous @I’m sorry.Dec. 21, 2024 (Sat) 16:01:21.28ID:w6DmcAF80
If you get tired of it, you can just sell it.
31Anonymous @I’m sorry.Dec. 21, 2024 (Sat) 16:01:22.26ID:jT2SdIDQ0
Much better than the gacha in smartphone games.
41Anonymous @I’m sorry.Dec. 21, 2024 (Sat) 16:02:49.20ID:7WmDNTNX0
>>31
There are people who spend enough to buy not just the software but the hardware in one go
And if you’re a collector, you do it every time.
34Anonymous @I’m sorry.Dec. 21, 2024 (Sat) 16:01:40.65ID:EbYl6XVO0
I wonder if he’ll faint if he sees the amounts people who spend a lot on gacha spend.
35Anonymous @I’m sorry.Dec. 21, 2024 (Sat) 16:01:54.84ID:L4JhdMNz0
Well, I guess I’ll have to somehow get it for 5,000 yen.
38Anonymous @I’m sorry.Dec. 21, 2024 (Sat) 16:02:21.47ID:Mjj+qlh20
That’s the sort of thing an idiot who only cares about consuming would say.
39Anonymous @I’m sorry.Dec. 21, 2024 (Sat) 16:02:28.73ID:CYoL2YmR0
In the board game world, the maximum is around 50,000.
40Anonymous @I’m sorry.Dec. 21, 2024 (Sat) 16:02:49.10ID:P12aqSMx0
Social games cost 3000 yen per character, so each game seems really cheap to me. I’m just numb to it.
42Anonymous @I’m sorry.Dec. 21, 2024 (Sat) 16:02:56.35ID:GB0TO62Y0
If we’re talking about cost-effectiveness, YouTube and Amazon Prime are probably the best. Unlike games, they don’t cost much money.
43Anonymous @I’m sorry.Dec. 21, 2024 (Sat) 16:03:04.91ID:feChyFK30
Square RPGs on PS are just too much. There’s an incredible amount of text and settings.
45Anonymous @I’m sorry.Dec. 21, 2024 (Sat) 16:03:30.28ID:PPhTy/jw0
Super Nintendo software is sometimes even more expensive.
47Anonymous @I’m sorry.Dec. 21, 2024 (Sat) 16:03:56.25ID:5s8QBwpE0
I think games like Minecraft, Factorio, and Civilization are reducing the productivity of the Earth.
49Approved.Dec. 21, 2024 (Sat) 16:04:19.15ID:hkYNWuPV0
First of all, you buy it without knowing if you’ll enjoy it.
50Anonymous @I’m sorry.Dec. 21, 2024 (Sat) 16:04:27.71ID:2ueoY8w+0
Koei cost about 15,000 yen during its SFC days.
52Anonymous @I’m sorry.Dec. 21, 2024 (Sat) 16:05:03.91ID:mo92BZQI0
>>50
For Neo Geo, the software costs around 30,000-40,000 yen each…
51Anonymous @I’m sorry.Dec. 21, 2024 (Sat) 16:04:35.64ID:mo92BZQI0
Well, this is a question of values.
Reference: https://hayabusa9.5ch.net/test/read.cgi/mnewsplus/1734764024

Other languages: 「ゲームに7000円出す価値ある?高過ぎでは?」質問にツッコミ殺到「100時間遊べば1時間70円」「時間単価で映画より安い」, ”¿Vale la pena pagar 7.000 yenes por un juego? ¿No es demasiado caro?” La pregunta se vio inundada de tsukkomi: ”Si juegas 100 horas, cuesta 70 yenes la hora”. Es más barato que una película”.

Comments

Copied title and URL