Is “no makeup allowed” sexual harassment? Instructing certain female employees to wear makeup “not acceptable”

apparel
0001Shoko-san ★Jul. 13, 2024 (Sat) 09:28:17.17ID:P2tZMevL9
Is “no makeup” sexual harassment? Only certain female employees are instructed to wear makeup “I don’t understand” – Bengo4.com
July 13, 2024 9:12am
#No makeup#Principle of good faith
Is a company’s instruction to prohibit wearing makeup sexual harassment or power harassment?
Bengoshi4.com received such a consultation.
The consultant is a woman working as a temporary employee at a major company. She says that she understands the need to wear makeup as part of her appearance because she works in sales.
However, due to the increase in remote work caused by COVID-19, she has almost stopped wearing makeup. She also says, “Just like male employees, I am careful about wrinkles in my hair and suit.”
Meanwhile, a colleague at work told her, “No makeup allowed from tomorrow.” Since other women in the same department have not been told anything, she is outraged, saying, “I don’t understand,” suspecting that “people are telling me about my makeup based on whether I look good or bad.”
Is it legal for a company to prohibit employees from wearing makeup like this? We asked lawyer Tomoe Terabayashi.
● Instructing only women to wear makeup is gender discrimination
First of all, in general terms, explicitly instructing only women to wear makeup in a work rule constitutes gender discrimination, and such a rule would be invalid as it violates the principle of good faith (Article 1 of the Civil Code).
Also, as in this case, it can be said that forcing a company or superior to prohibit a specific woman from wearing makeup and to wear makeup constitutes sexual harassment.
According to the national definition, sexual harassment refers to (1) sexual verbal or physical actions in the workplace that make others uncomfortable, and (2) sexual verbal or physical actions outside the workplace that make other employees uncomfortable, and sexual verbal or physical actions include “verbal or physical actions based on the belief that roles should be divided according to gender.”
Forcing a specific woman to wear makeup and a company or superior to prohibit her from wearing makeup can be said to be “verbal or physical actions based on the belief that roles should be divided according to gender” or something equivalent.
Therefore, it constitutes sexual harassment.
● Treating someone unfavorably because they are not wearing makeup is power harassment
Furthermore, if you treat someone unfavorably, such as transferring them to an unwanted department, or even hint at it, because they are not wearing makeup, that also constitutes power harassment.
(Omitted)
※See source for full text.

「すっぴん禁止」はセクハラ? 特定の女性社員だけに化粧の指示 「納得いきません」 - 弁護士ドットコムニュース
スッピン禁止という会社の指示はセクハラやパワハラになりますかーー。弁護士ドットコムにそんな相談が寄せられました。相談者は女性で、ある大手企業の派遣社員として働いています。営業職のため身だしなみ...
0049Anonymous DonburakoJul. 13, 2024 (Sat) 09:42:01.75ID:YMo/+N0d0
>>1
I understand how you feel, but if you want to fight, be prepared to quit your job.
Normal people don’t fight and just wear light makeup.
If you have a skin condition that prevents you from wearing makeup, you can submit a medical certificate and be approved.
0003Anonymous DonburakoJul. 13, 2024 (Sat) 09:29:19.39ID:R+D3wINk0
For men, it’s like not shaving your beard. It’s good manners to be well-groomed.
0011Anonymous DonburakoJul. 13, 2024 (Sat) 09:31:47.03ID:1oacpbf00
>>3
This is a case of at least using common sense.
0020Anonymous DonburakoJul. 13, 2024 (Sat) 09:35:06.06ID:8n/KktHY0(1/3)
>>3
You think women don’t shave?
0023Anonymous DonburakoJul. 13, 2024 (Sat) 09:36:49.10ID:anovzjgZ0(1/2)
>>3
I feel it’s a bit sad that girls are banned from wearing makeup in high school, but it becomes compulsory after graduation.
0032Anonymous DonburakoJul. 13, 2024 (Sat) 09:38:25.02ID:xf66l0ca0
>>3
They probably think women can’t grow beards
0110Anonymous DonburakoJul. 13, 2024 (Sat) 10:14:31.42ID:Hm2IzDUa0(1/4)
>>3
Feminists say that’s gender discrimination lol
And women grow beards too.
0005Anonymous DonburakoJul. 13, 2024 (Sat) 09:29:56.37ID:0
Freedom of occupational choice
Yes, refuted
0006Anonymous DonburakoJul. 13, 2024 (Sat) 09:30:46.72ID:KhISuYYa0
That’s rude. Just shut up and do what you’re told.
0008Anonymous DonburakoJul. 13, 2024 (Sat) 09:30:55.48ID:q+ZapcbK0
It would be fine if she hadn’t done anything with her eyebrows. She shaved them but still didn’t draw them. She’s a monster.
0013Security Guard [lv.17]Jul. 13, 2024 (Sat) 09:32:33.53ID:uTIlY7XG0
It depends on what kind of company it is. If it’s a cosmetics company…
0014Anonymous DonburakoJul. 13, 2024 (Sat) 09:32:38.32ID:s2reTQP40
The validity of face-based hiring has been proven.
0015Anonymous DonburakoJul. 13, 2024 (Sat) 09:32:40.88ID:gH0UAYQf0
I love no makeup
0016Anonymous DonburakoJul. 13, 2024 (Sat) 09:32:44.55ID:MFEPRXOZ0
Let’s say you don’t want to come out of the air-conditioned room because you’ll end up covered in sweat.
0017Anonymous DonburakoJul. 13, 2024 (Sat) 09:32:49.44ID:yejPmCtM0
Well, there are also rules against beards and long hair for men, so we should discuss those as well.
0062Anonymous DonburakoJul. 13, 2024 (Sat) 09:45:40.42ID:lms0cfSQ0
>>17
The Giants don’t allow beards
Apparently their motto is “Be a gentleman”
I don’t understand what a beard has to do with being a gentleman lol
And yet they signed Nakata Sho, who caused a violent incident with the Nippon-Ham Fighters, so I don’t get it lol
0018Anonymous DonburakoJul. 13, 2024 (Sat) 09:33:32.44ID:GDTPUGhi0
Ah, that’s bothersome.
0019Anonymous DonburakoJul. 13, 2024 (Sat) 09:34:34.50ID:8lTbaS1Z0
I would rather ask her to wear no makeup.
0021Anonymous DonburakoJul. 13, 2024 (Sat) 09:35:46.20ID:oSPL7uc40(1/3)
If you have no eyes or eyebrows in a remote meeting, it’s pretty noticeable.
0024Guard [lv.7] [Seedling]Jul. 13, 2024 (Sat) 09:36:50.18ID:d2vjjVob0(2/3)
>>21
Not to mention the eyebrows, there are no eyes lol
0026Anonymous DonburakoJul. 13, 2024 (Sat) 09:37:43.29ID:anovzjgZ0(2/2)
>>21
What do you mean no eyes lol
0025Anonymous DonburakoJul. 13, 2024 (Sat) 09:36:53.03ID:2RV6wzwi0
I don’t think or say anything about people who you can tell just by looking at them that they’re wearing natural makeup. Please don’t suddenly go without makeup. It’s physically scary.
0027Anonymous DonburakoJul. 13, 2024 (Sat) 09:37:57.93ID:yzVxxCyO0(1/2)
But when I ask her to come without makeup, she gets mad
0029Guard [lv.5] [Sprout]Jul. 13, 2024 (Sat) 09:38:12.67ID:ymrUWivp0
Am I the only one who thinks people look like monsters when they wear makeup?
I feel scared when I see their eyes and unnaturally white skin that looks like they’ve been painted on.
0031Anonymous DonburakoJul. 13, 2024 (Sat) 09:38:21.94ID:xzKVAtZh0
So should men wear makeup too?
0035Anonymous DonburakoJul. 13, 2024 (Sat) 09:38:59.12ID:746OLn9R0
Makeup is good manners
0037Anonymous DonburakoJul. 13, 2024 (Sat) 09:39:14.90ID:8n/KktHY0(2/3)
No baldness allowed
0038Anonymous DonburakoJul. 13, 2024 (Sat) 09:39:25.74ID:t4/TMAuD0
If you draw your eyebrows, the rest will be fine with a mask.
0040Anonymous DonburakoJul. 13, 2024 (Sat) 09:39:44.13ID:93sIVXJP0(1/2)
In that case, cheating is also prohibited
0041Anonymous DonburakoJul. 13, 2024 (Sat) 09:39:48.96ID:7+6mpOUm0
Nowadays, even men wear makeup, so it’s outdated if both men and women don’t wear it if they want to. Same goes for shoes. Forcing women to wear pumps and stockings is an old-fashioned bad custom.
0042Anonymous DonburakoJul. 13, 2024 (Sat) 09:40:04.45ID:Jo4g07Cq0
I wonder if only beautiful people are forced to wear makeup or the other way around?
0043Anonymous DonburakoJul. 13, 2024 (Sat) 09:40:05.72ID:ce63r01A0
Why not ban men from wearing no makeup too?
Reference: https://asahi.5ch.net/test/read.cgi/newsplus/1720830497

Other languages: 「すっぴん禁止」はセクハラ?特定の女性社員だけに化粧の指示「納得いきません」

Comments

Copied title and URL