After Japan’s October 27 election, replies to the Ministry of Finance’s X posts surged 15x, with many demanding reforms or abolition.
1Flea market ★.Nov. 24, 2024 (Sun) 07:45:40.54ID:iPM6/jdo9
Since the House of Representatives election on October 27th, posts on the Ministry of Finance’s official x (formerly Twitter) account have been inundated with critical replies. The number of replies has increased by more than 15 times since before the election, and most of them criticize and slander the ministry, with comments such as “dismantling the Ministry of Finance” and “Zaim Shinrikyo.” It has been pointed out that the background to this is criticism of the Ministry of Finance’s resistance to the Democratic Party for the People’s proposal to abolish the “1.03 million yen barrier.” Too heated… Tamaki: “Let’s have a calm discussion”
The number of replies to the Ministry of Finance’s x posts averaged 65 per post between May 15, 2022, when data became available, and the House of Representatives election on October 27 this year. However, after the House of Representatives election, the average number of cases increased to 1,013, a 15.6-fold increase. The situation has become so heated that on November 14, Yuichiro Tamaki, the leader of the Democratic Party for the People and a former Ministry of Finance official, called for “calm and constructive discussion” in his speech. Regarding this situation, Yamaguchi Shinichi, an associate professor of social information studies at the International University of Japan, said, “In the House of Representatives election, the Democratic Party for the People made great strides by putting forward the abolition of the ‘1.03 million yen wall,’ but the Ministry of Finance showed resistance. This has given internet users a clear enemy to criticize.” (Omitted)
20,000 posts, 92% of which were negative. (omitted)
92 hashtags, 180 posts about “dismantling the Ministry of Finance”
An analysis of the content of 783 replies or mentions posted to the Ministry of Finance account during the 24 hours from 7 p.m. on November 16th showed that the second most commonly used word after “Ministry of Finance” was “dismantling.” It was included in 270 cases, or 34% of the total, and in 180 of those cases it was used as “dismantling the Ministry of Finance.” The “Zaim Shinrikyo” cult, which mocks the government’s strict stance on fiscal discipline, appeared 18 times. (Omitted). Associate Professor Yamaguchi said, “Opinions on the Internet have begun to have a momentum that changes the opinions of the majority. “These most recent elections are a clear turning point.” On the other hand, “Easy-to-understand conflicts are easily spread online, but the content of policies is what is questioned. “When online discussions become excessive or extreme, it becomes difficult to have substantive discussion,” he warns. (Data analyst Nishiyama Ryo)
Sankei Shimbun 2024/11/23 15:30.
The number of replies to the Ministry of Finance’s x posts averaged 65 per post between May 15, 2022, when data became available, and the House of Representatives election on October 27 this year. However, after the House of Representatives election, the average number of cases increased to 1,013, a 15.6-fold increase. The situation has become so heated that on November 14, Yuichiro Tamaki, the leader of the Democratic Party for the People and a former Ministry of Finance official, called for “calm and constructive discussion” in his speech. Regarding this situation, Yamaguchi Shinichi, an associate professor of social information studies at the International University of Japan, said, “In the House of Representatives election, the Democratic Party for the People made great strides by putting forward the abolition of the ‘1.03 million yen wall,’ but the Ministry of Finance showed resistance. This has given internet users a clear enemy to criticize.” (Omitted)
20,000 posts, 92% of which were negative. (omitted)
92 hashtags, 180 posts about “dismantling the Ministry of Finance”
An analysis of the content of 783 replies or mentions posted to the Ministry of Finance account during the 24 hours from 7 p.m. on November 16th showed that the second most commonly used word after “Ministry of Finance” was “dismantling.” It was included in 270 cases, or 34% of the total, and in 180 of those cases it was used as “dismantling the Ministry of Finance.” The “Zaim Shinrikyo” cult, which mocks the government’s strict stance on fiscal discipline, appeared 18 times. (Omitted). Associate Professor Yamaguchi said, “Opinions on the Internet have begun to have a momentum that changes the opinions of the majority. “These most recent elections are a clear turning point.” On the other hand, “Easy-to-understand conflicts are easily spread online, but the content of policies is what is questioned. “When online discussions become excessive or extreme, it becomes difficult to have substantive discussion,” he warns. (Data analyst Nishiyama Ryo)
Sankei Shimbun 2024/11/23 15:30.
財務省への批判がXで急増、リプライは衆院選後15倍以上に 殺到の批判コメントを可視化
財務省のX(旧ツイッター)公式アカウントの投稿に対し、10月27日の衆院選以降、批判的なリプライ(返信)が殺到している。選挙前に比べて返信の数は15倍以上に増…
4Anonymous Donburako.Nov. 24, 2024 (Sun) 07:47:37.75ID:RhitOFou0
Finance Ministry dog: “So where does the funding come from?”
18Anonymous Donburako.Nov. 24, 2024 (Sun) 07:52:34.69ID:oyX9ZvvY0
>>4
I think it would be good to establish a new amakudari tax.
I think it would be good to establish a new amakudari tax.
30Anonymous Donburako.Nov. 24, 2024 (Sun) 07:55:35.45ID:BuXjm2Ey0
>>4
If the Ministry of Finance were to issue currency, this would be easily solved.
If the Ministry of Finance were to issue currency, this would be easily solved.
5Anonymous Donburako.Nov. 24, 2024 (Sun) 07:47:39.50ID:aAUY8kQQ0
How many US Treasury bonds can you buy? That’s it, Treasury.
6Anonymous Donburako.Nov. 24, 2024 (Sun) 07:47:39.52ID:+r+9MW/k0
NHK was also dismantled.
7Anonymous Donburako.Nov. 24, 2024 (Sun) 07:47:45.76ID:FUuVPybk0
The more minority they are, the more vocal and persistent they are.
8Anonymous Donburako.Nov. 24, 2024 (Sun) 07:47:50.56ID:wWe7zVBr0
That’s right. They only care about increasing their own money by raising taxes.
9Anonymous Donburako.Nov. 24, 2024 (Sun) 07:47:51.97ID:Ko3Cm3qd0
Since it’s anonymous, it’s okay to write sarcastic comments, “I’m so cool,” a small-time idiot.
12Anonymous Donburako.Nov. 24, 2024 (Sun) 07:49:08.71ID:WeW1v60c0
>>9
Example
The Ministry of Finance should be dismantled.
Example
The Ministry of Finance should be dismantled.
10Anonymous Donburako.Nov. 24, 2024 (Sun) 07:48:05.68ID:AgxkSfDa0
The enemy is the Kasumigaseki bureaucrats!
Stand up, people!
Stand up, people!
11Anonymous Donburako.Nov. 24, 2024 (Sun) 07:48:06.57ID:M6E4L0A80
I understand the anger, but writing criticism on official social media is no different from slander.
15Anonymous Donburako.Nov. 24, 2024 (Sun) 07:50:24.97ID:RhitOFou0
>>11
Then where should I write this?
Just bear with it.
Then where should I write this?
Just bear with it.
20Anonymous Donburako.Nov. 24, 2024 (Sun) 07:52:59.31ID:Gf49JpAn0
Ministry of Tax Increase.
21Anonymous Donburako.Nov. 24, 2024 (Sun) 07:53:02.35ID:itsHHojb0
Oh? I thought you shouldn’t trust social media?
Now it seems like the voice of the people is being heard
The media is on a roll.
Now it seems like the voice of the people is being heard
The media is on a roll.
22Anonymous Donburako.Nov. 24, 2024 (Sun) 07:53:06.61ID:tXlzHrT40
Why are right-wing netizens attacking the Ministry of Finance and defending the Ministry of Economy, Trade and Industry? It used to be different.
24Anonymous Donburako.Nov. 24, 2024 (Sun) 07:53:50.64ID:lmY4DuuR0
Are these borderline intelligent people who easily believe delusions such as conspiracy theories really trying to destroy Japan?
25Anonymous Donburako.Nov. 24, 2024 (Sun) 07:54:08.70ID:kylqECHB0
What interests me most is the reality of extramarital affairs among Ministry of Finance officials.
26Anonymous Donburako.Nov. 24, 2024 (Sun) 07:55:07.98ID:7HKONhZo0
Is this also employed by a company?
28Anonymous Donburako.Nov. 24, 2024 (Sun) 07:55:20.44ID:F0Wx+ptZ0
Let’s create a Ministry of Finance by completely replacing all personnel.
29Anonymous Donburako.Nov. 24, 2024 (Sun) 07:55:30.91ID:OuCp0F2g0
They are a quiet people who are satisfied just by letting off steam with x.
31Anonymous Donburako.Nov. 24, 2024 (Sun) 07:55:36.88ID:xtFpHKR70
I guess no one can bear it anymore without a visible villain. It’s on the same level as China and Korea’s past hostile policies towards Japan.
32Anonymous Donburako.Nov. 24, 2024 (Sun) 07:55:45.04ID:DT9rWPG50
It’s just written by scumbags who don’t want to pay a cent in taxes or pensions.
34Anonymous Donburako.Nov. 24, 2024 (Sun) 07:56:09.52ID:klEOh7Gb0
Like the company employee who was working on planning election strategies for the Hyogo Prefectural Governor election, if your social media account goes viral, you can just delete your account and run away. With new media, you can do that.
35Anonymous Donburako.Nov. 24, 2024 (Sun) 07:56:16.79ID:635lPRoU0
Prices are rising and taxes are increasing. I feel bad for them, because their retirement benefits are in jeopardy.
36Anonymous Donburako.Nov. 24, 2024 (Sun) 07:57:01.35ID:xtFpHKR70
Well, it’s probably only a matter of time before the visible enemy changes from the government to the people next door. The time when we will kill others for a meal is fast approaching.
37Anonymous Donburako.Nov. 24, 2024 (Sun) 07:57:55.13ID:635lPRoU0
The time is fast approaching when people who live outside of two-level security will be considered bad people.
39Anonymous Donburako.Nov. 24, 2024 (Sun) 07:59:26.65ID:4I3yTcAK0
Have they ever had a meaningful discussion? They’re always just Finance Ministry dog politicians.
40Security Guard [lv.16].Nov. 24, 2024 (Sun) 07:59:27.37ID:krvfnOZt0
Well, the Ministry of Finance has raised taxes too much, so this disaster can’t be helped.
41Anonymous Donburako.Nov. 24, 2024 (Sun) 07:59:46.86ID:2HhMGv4o0
It’s easy for Japanese people because there are only losers who complain on the internet. Riots would have already broken out overseas. Even if 90% of their income was taken in taxes and they were on the verge of starvation, Japanese people would just complain on the internet.
47Anonymous Donburako.Nov. 24, 2024 (Sun) 08:05:07.37ID:PS/PU/MG0
We don’t need the money to hand out, but we do need the money to raise the wall, so it’s no wonder they’re getting criticized.
Comments