Japan’s Ministry of Education estimates free school lunches need $3 billion yearly, citing fairness and disparity concerns.
1Flea market ★.Dec. 28, 2024 (Sat) 07:50:26.42ID:3USiE1nR9
On the 27th, the Ministry of Education, Culture, Sports, Science and Technology announced the challenges that would arise if free school lunches were implemented nationwide. After stating an estimate that a financial resource of approximately 483.2 billion yen would be needed per year, the report cited four reasons, including the fact that some schools do not provide school lunches, raising doubts about fairness, and expressed caution about making school lunches free. According to a survey by the ministry, as of September last year, 722 local governments (40% of the total) were independently implementing free school lunch programs at public elementary and junior high schools. The purposes of making it free were “child-rearing support” and “measures to combat the declining birthrate.” In response, the ministry cited four issues that would arise if free school lunches were implemented across the board: (1) There are 610,000 children and students (6% of the total) at schools that do not provide school lunches, raising questions about fairness; (2) School lunches for low-income households are basically free, making this inappropriate as a measure to correct disparities; (3) The appropriateness of using national funds to provide free school lunches to low-income households, which is currently done using local government funds, is questionable; and (4) If the purpose is to combat the declining birthrate, the effectiveness of the measure needs to be examined. Regarding free school lunches, the Constitutional Democratic Party, the Japan Restoration Party, and the Democratic Party for the People jointly submitted a bill to the House of Representatives on the 23rd to implement the scheme from next fiscal year. Yomiuri Shimbun 2024/12/28 06:50.
「給食無償化」年4832億円の財源必要、文科省が推計…「公平性に疑問」「格差是正策として適当でない」指摘
【読売新聞】 文部科学省は27日、学校給食の無償化を全国一律で実施した場合の課題を公表した。年間約4832億円の財源が必要との推計を示した上で、給食を実施していない学校もあり公平性に疑問があるなど4点を挙げ、無償化に慎重な考えを示し
8Anonymous Donburako.Dec. 28, 2024 (Sat) 07:52:13.21ID:nYcmqL/Y0
>>1
It would be better to cut taxes by 483.2 billion yen.
It would be better to cut taxes by 483.2 billion yen.
34Anonymous Donburako.Dec. 28, 2024 (Sat) 08:00:32.15ID:M88rs+qW0
>>1
Kasumigaseki is cutting the budget with quibbling arguments.
Kasumigaseki is cutting the budget with quibbling arguments.
2Anonymous Donburako.Dec. 28, 2024 (Sat) 07:51:35.07ID:FpgT+i5H0
It would be fair to make it so that everyone is denied school lunches.
60Anonymous Donburako.Dec. 28, 2024 (Sat) 08:06:11.43ID:CKf0Flyb0
>>2
Correct.
Correct.
4Anonymous Donburako.Dec. 28, 2024 (Sat) 07:51:50.20ID:lTmZxhM50
How far are they going to pamper low-income families?
Surely parents should be responsible for their children’s meals.
Surely parents should be responsible for their children’s meals.
38Anonymous Donburako.Dec. 28, 2024 (Sat) 08:01:45.65ID:06tIEcgN0
>>4
When single, childless people become elderly, who will pay for Japan’s infrastructure and social security costs?
When single, childless people become elderly, who will pay for Japan’s infrastructure and social security costs?
5Anonymous Donburako.Dec. 28, 2024 (Sat) 07:52:00.70ID:NAWGLOYb0
Just hand out meal vouchers to children.
6Security guard [lv.8].Dec. 28, 2024 (Sat) 07:52:06.55ID:rp/9rw7a0
It’s better than giving cash.
9Anonymous Donburako.Dec. 28, 2024 (Sat) 07:53:51.67ID:37k5A1HU0
The root cause of the declining birthrate is single people over 40 not getting married, having kids, and living as they please, so we should confiscate the retirement savings of these damn single people as a singles tax and use that money as a source of revenue.
10Anonymous Donburako.Dec. 28, 2024 (Sat) 07:53:56.55ID:zLolu3MB0
There’s no benefit to families without children or no school involvement. It’s unfair and a terrible law.
22Security Guard [lv.9] [Sprout].Dec. 28, 2024 (Sat) 07:57:06.22ID:Jntt1Rb00
>>10
What are you going to do about your social security and infrastructure?
What are you going to do about your social security and infrastructure?
13Anonymous Donburako.Dec. 28, 2024 (Sat) 07:54:31.22ID:TdAKHM6C0
And for the lower classes, the funds will be available immediately!
14Anonymous Donburako.Dec. 28, 2024 (Sat) 07:54:59.38ID:D9pUjWT40
We didn’t have school lunches in my middle school. I don’t know about now though.
15Anonymous Donburako.Dec. 28, 2024 (Sat) 07:54:59.78ID:a4dd+AoG0
In today’s pyramid scheme economy, the gap is bound to widen, so is it stupid to try to correct the gap?
18Anonymous Donburako.Dec. 28, 2024 (Sat) 07:56:16.64ID:lTmZxhM50
It seems like saying “For the sake of children! To combat the declining birthrate!” is just an excuse to be told, “Well, that can’t be helped!”
For the sake of children!
For the sake of women!
These things make opponents cautious, so they can say whatever they want.
21Anonymous Donburako.Dec. 28, 2024 (Sat) 07:57:00.67ID:7FYcvlFO0
What if we reduced the pensions of lawmakers?
62Anonymous Donburako.Dec. 28, 2024 (Sat) 08:06:50.90ID:Vlyxlvey0
>>21
Don’t you know that that was abolished a long time ago?
Don’t you know that that was abolished a long time ago?
23[Great fortune]Dec. 28, 2024 (Sat) 07:57:48.49ID:t28MdrN80
Or rather, aren’t there anybody willing to work in the food service industry? It seems like it’s not profitable.
24Anonymous Donburako.Dec. 28, 2024 (Sat) 07:57:53.41ID:E/VqHlpe0
I remember a while ago, I was in response to news that a decision had been made to raise salaries for civil servants, either at the local or national level, which would result in an increase in spending of about 380 billion yen, and the civil servant comment team was writing comments like, “It’s a necessary expense! It’s a necessary expense!”
25Anonymous Donburako.Dec. 28, 2024 (Sat) 07:58:11.12ID:izKcDWY+0
Let’s have a party and get together.
44Anonymous Donburako.Dec. 28, 2024 (Sat) 08:02:38.89ID:FpfSm3J00
>>25
Japanese party politicians are already under preliminary investigation by police in major countries.
Apparently, it’s bribery.
Japanese party politicians are already under preliminary investigation by police in major countries.
Apparently, it’s bribery.
26Anonymous Donburako.Dec. 28, 2024 (Sat) 07:58:29.30ID:x8aOlk5z0
400 billion yen cut.
27Anonymous Donburako.Dec. 28, 2024 (Sat) 07:58:32.81ID:X6nxiOKz0
I also want to go to elementary school for lunch and eat some junior high school food while I’m there.
31Anonymous Donburako.Dec. 28, 2024 (Sat) 07:59:33.99ID:iY1/kxge0
Let those who can help themselves help themselves. The rich are not only not short of money, they are making more money than ever before.
32Anonymous Donburako.Dec. 28, 2024 (Sat) 07:59:35.50ID:n1h9VH7S0
Everything is too slow. I’m sick of it.
35Anonymous Donburako.Dec. 28, 2024 (Sat) 08:00:36.85ID:FpfSm3J00
It would be quicker to just cut taxes to make up for that.
Tax revenue is just money sucked out of the people.
It’s the people’s money to begin with, so isn’t it just a case of taking it from their pockets without any middlemen?
Plus, taxes aren’t the source of revenue.
Tax revenue is just money sucked out of the people.
It’s the people’s money to begin with, so isn’t it just a case of taking it from their pockets without any middlemen?
Plus, taxes aren’t the source of revenue.
49Anonymous Donburako.Dec. 28, 2024 (Sat) 08:03:33.81ID:Cz0BeiUF0
>>35
Cutting the middleman seems stupid.
Cutting the middleman seems stupid.
36Anonymous Donburako.Dec. 28, 2024 (Sat) 08:01:16.73ID:CTLN5bYS0
If poor people have children, it just creates a negative spiral and their tax burden increases.
39Anonymous Donburako.Dec. 28, 2024 (Sat) 08:01:59.85ID:37k5A1HU0
Let’s confiscate the savings of these damn single people who don’t marry or have kids and just live as they please as a singles tax and use that as a source of revenue. The declining birthrate is their fault, so don’t spoil them.
54Anonymous Donburako.Dec. 28, 2024 (Sat) 08:04:57.23ID:FpfSm3J00
>>39
Taxes aren’t really the source of revenue lol
Japan has been stagnant for 30 years already, right?
It’s all about the middleman and the cum shot lol.
Taxes aren’t really the source of revenue lol
Japan has been stagnant for 30 years already, right?
It’s all about the middleman and the cum shot lol.
56Anonymous Donburako.Dec. 28, 2024 (Sat) 08:05:09.48ID:7kvZWJFt0
>>39
Well, I probably earn more than you,
but I’d be happy to have children if you could match me with a beautiful woman or girl
I’d decline, though, because childcare is too much work.
Well, I probably earn more than you,
but I’d be happy to have children if you could match me with a beautiful woman or girl
I’d decline, though, because childcare is too much work.
89Anonymous Donburako.Dec. 28, 2024 (Sat) 08:14:51.14ID:90VHQKJm0
>>39
Well, I probably earn more than you
I’d be happy to have a child if you could match me with a beautiful woman or girl
I’d decline because childcare is too much work
The writing of people with developmental disabilities is easy to understand.
Well, I probably earn more than you
I’d be happy to have a child if you could match me with a beautiful woman or girl
I’d decline because childcare is too much work
The writing of people with developmental disabilities is easy to understand.
40Anonymous Donburako.Dec. 28, 2024 (Sat) 08:02:01.88ID:cXR316xr0
Stop whining and just make it free.
42Anonymous Donburako.Dec. 28, 2024 (Sat) 08:02:17.06ID:oNLsupyO0
I don’t know much about that, but I wonder where the huge amount of funds from the head of child support goes.
45Anonymous Donburako.Dec. 28, 2024 (Sat) 08:02:48.77ID:vAME3tKD0
I’ve been eating bento since I was in middle school, so I thought it was the same at every school in the country.
50Anonymous Donburako.Dec. 28, 2024 (Sat) 08:03:35.19ID:Fs79dLfj0
So stop talking about making it free.
It’s not like it will be a tax burden.
It’s not like politicians will have to pay for it.
It’s not like it will be a tax burden.
It’s not like politicians will have to pay for it.
57Anonymous Donburako.Dec. 28, 2024 (Sat) 08:05:31.64ID:NAWGLOYb0
So we should just provide a flat-rate childcare allowance. This country is full of idiots.
Other languages: 「給食無償化」文科省年4832億円の財源必要と推計し「公平性に疑問」「格差是正策として適当でない」指摘, El Ministerio de Educación, Cultura, Deportes, Ciencia y Tecnología estima que ”los almuerzos escolares gratuitos” requerirán 483.200 millones de yenes al año, y señala que ”la equidad es cuestionable” y ”no es apropiada como medida para corregir las disparidades”.
Comments